All Issue

2021 Vol.14, Issue 3

Original Article

Preliminary Feasibility Study for Water Resources Policy Effect Analysis Direction

수자원분야 예비타당성 조사 정책효과 분석 방향

Yeonjeong Seong1
,
Seungan Choi2
,
Hyun-Han Kwon3
,
Younghun Jung4*
성 연정1
,
최 승안2
,
권 현한3
,
정 영훈4*
1Ph.D Student, Dept. of Advance Science and Technology Convergence, Kyungpook National Univ.
2Research Fellow, Public and Private Infrastructure Investment Management Center, Korea Development Institute
3Professor, Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Sejong Univ.
4Professor, Dept. of Advance Science and Technology Convergence, Kyungpook National Univ.
1경북대학교 미래과학기술융합학과 박사과정
2한국개발연구원 공공투자관리센터 전문위원
3세종대학교 건설환경공학과 교수
4경북대학교 미래과학기술융합학과 교수
*Corresponding Author
30 September 2021. pp. 1-16
PDF XML Citation
Abstract

Recently, large-scale projects are required in the water resources sector considering safety and publicitythe due to uncertainty of securing water resources and changes in the ecological environment by climate change. Among these large-scale projects, the projects that fall under the preliminary feasibility study are determined by comprehensive analysis based on economic analysis, policy analysis, and balanced regional development analysis. However, most of the results of the preliminary feasibility study showed a tendency to depend heavily on economic analysis. For this reason, projects in non-metropolitan areas sometimes fail in the preliminary feasibility study. To supplement this point, the Korea Development Institute revised the standard guidelines for preliminary feasibility studies for water resources sector projects that place a high weight on policy feasibility analysis. Therefore, the objective of this study is to analyze the cases of the preliminary feasibility study conducted previously and to suggest the direction of policy analysis in the preliminary feasibility study for water resources sector projects. For this, we analyze preliminary feasibility studies conducted for 18 years from 2002 to 2019, and suggest direction of policy analysis method using the benefit items not included in the economic analysis.

Keywords
Policy analysis
Preliminary feasibility study
Cost-benefit analysis
AHP
Economic analysis

최근 기후변화로 인한 수자원 확보의 불확실성과 생태환경의 변화에 따라 안전성과 공공성을 고려한 수자원 분야에 대형 사업이 요구된다. 이러한 대형 사업가운데 예비타당성사업에 해당되는 사업은 국가예산낭비 예방의 목적으로 경제성분석과, 정책성분석, 지역균형발전 분석에 기반한 종합분석에 의하여 사업추진이 결정된다. 그러나 대부분 예비타당성분석에 의한 결과는 경제성분석에 크게 의존하는 경향을 보여 비수도권 지역에서는 예비타당성조사를 통과하지 못하는 경우가 있었다. 이러한 점을 보완하기 위해 한국개발연구원에서는 정책성분석의 비중을 높게 두는 수자원부문 사업의 예비타당성조사 표준지침을 수정하였다. 따라서 본 연구에서는 기존 수행된 예비타당성조사에 대한 사례를 분석하고 수자원부문 사업의 예비타당성조사에서 정책성분석의 방향을 제시하는 것이 목표이다. 이에 지난 2002년부터 2019년까지 18년간 수행된 수자원분야 예비타당성 사례조사를 수행하였고, 경제성분석에 포함되지 않는 편익항목을 이용하여 정책적효과 분석방안을 제시하였다.

키워드
정책적분석
예비타당성조사
비용편익분석
AHP
경제성분석
References
1
Korea Development Institute (2000). Connective Operation Project of Waterworks Supply Facilities. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
2
Korea Development Institute (2002a). Redevelopment Project of Goesan Dam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
3
Korea Development Institute (2002b). Redevelopment Project of Maehwa Dam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
4
Korea Development Institute (2002c). Redevelopment Project of Sinpwoong․Seongdeok Dam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
5
Korea Development Institute (2002d). Redevelopment Project of Obong Dam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
6
Korea Development Institute (2002e). Construction Project of Imjin River Gunnam Flood Lake Control Facilities. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
7
Korea Development Institute (2003a). Construction Project of Sokasa dam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
8
Korea Development Institute (2003b). Construction Project of Anui Dam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
9
Korea Development Institute (2003c). Construction Project of Ian River Dam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
10
Korea Development Institute (2003d). 1st Project to Build a Water Supply System of Downstream in Han River. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
11
Korea Development Institute (2004a). Extansion Project Preliminary Feasibility Study in Seawall Drain Gate of Asan Bay. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
12
Korea Development Institute (2004b). Improvement Project of Water Flow to Chopyeongdo in Imjin River. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
13
Korea Development Institute (2004c). Construction Project of South Area in Chungnam Wide-Area Waterworks. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
14
Korea Development Institute (2005a). Conctruction Project of Sentral Area in Gyeongbuk Wide-Area Waterworks. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
15
Korea Development Institute (2005b). Construction Project of Mokgam River Spilway and Dorim River Underground Spilway. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
16
Korea Development Institute (2006a). Water Development Project of Middle Scale (North Area in Andong). Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
17
Korea Development Institute (2006b). Reorganization Project of Using Agriculture Water System in Cheoldong District. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
18
Korea Development Institute (2007). Development Project of Middle Scale Rural Water in Baeksin District. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
19
Korea Development Institute (2008a). Wide-Area Waterworks Project of 3rd Level in Gumi. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
20
Korea Development Institute (2008b). Construction Project of Bohyeon Dam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
21
Korea Development Institute (2008c). Construction Project of Songliwon Multipurpose Dam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
22
Korea Development Institute (2008d). Increase Project of Juam Dam Flood Control. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
23
Korea Development Institute (2009a). Ecological River Creation Project of Gunsu District in Geum River Restoration. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
24
Korea Development Institute (2009b). Ecological River Creation Project of Sedo District in Geum River Restoration. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
25
Korea Development Institute (2009c). Ecological River Creation Project of Gumho District in Nakdong River Restoration. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
26
Korea Development Institute (2009d). Ecological River Creation Project of Dongchon District in Nakdong River Restoration. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
27
Korea Development Institute (2009e). Redevelopment Project of Namgang Dam and Wide-Area Waterworks Project of Busan and Gyeongnam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
28
Korea Development Institute (2009f). Construction of Daeam Dam Alternative Reservoir and Conveyance Pipeline. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
29
Korea Development Institute (2009g). Ecological River Creation Project of Donglim District in Yeongsan River Restoration. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
30
Korea Development Institute (2009h). Ecological River Creation Project of Hampyeong District 3 in Yeongsan River Restoration. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
31
Korea Development Institute (2009i). Rural Water Supply Measures Project of Imjin River Water System. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
32
Korea Development Institute (2009j). Construction Project of Danyang Submerged Weir in Chungju Lake. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
33
Korea Development Institute (2009k). 2nd Water Supply System Adjustment Project of Han River Downstream. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
34
Korea Development Institute (2010a). Ecological River Creation Project of Yangsan District 1 in Nakdong River Restoration. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
35
Korea Development Institute (2010b). Ecological River Creation Project of Yangsan District 2 in Nakdong River Restoration. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
36
Korea Development Institute (2010c). Embankment Build Project of Agricultural Reservoir (Baekgok). Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
37
Korea Development Institute (2010d). Wide-Area Waterworks Construction Project of Deacheung Dam System (III). Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
38
Korea Development Institute (2010e). Embankment Build Project of Yeongsan River Basin Agricultural Reservoir. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
39
Korea Development Institute (2011a). Construction Project of Dalsan Dam and Industrial Waterworks Build Project of Pohang (II). Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
40
Korea Development Institute (2011b). Construction Project of Yeongyang Dam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
41
Korea Development Institute (2011c). Industrial Waterworks Project of Chungju Dam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
42
Korea Development Institute (2012a). Water Supply Installation Project of Godeok Industrial Complex. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
43
Korea Development Institute (2012b). Riverside Filter Water Project of Nakdong River. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
44
Korea Development Institute (2012c). Drainage Gate Expansion Project of Sapgyo Breakwater. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
45
Korea Development Institute (2012d). Soil Inflow Prevention Facilities Construction Project of Andong Dam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
46
Korea Development Institute (2012e). Water Supply System Adjustment Project of 3rd Han River Downstream. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
47
Korea Development Institute (2013a). Wide-Area Waterworks Water Supply Reliability Enhancement Project of Capital Area (II). Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
48
Korea Development Institute (2013b). Research of General guidelines of Preliminary Feasibility Study to Corporation project. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
49
Korea Development Institute (2014). Reliability Adjustment Project of Gwangyang(Ⅰ) Industrial Waterworks Water Supply. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
50
Korea Development Institute (2016a). Ecological Stream Restoration Project of Downtown Stream in Gwangju River. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
51
Korea Development Institute (2016b). Restoration Project of Yongbong Ecological River. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
52
Korea Development Institute (2016c). Development Project of Jeomdong District Multipurpose Rural Water. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
53
Korea Development Institute (2016d). Understanding of Preliminary Feasibility Study System. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
54
Korea Development Institute (2017a). Project of Mokgam River(local river) Dimensions Counterplan. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
55
Korea Development Institute (2017b). project of National River Environment Maintenance in West Nakdong River Basin. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
56
Korea Development Institute (2017c). Wide-Area Waterworks Project of West-Area in Chungnam. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
57
Korea Development Institute (2017d). Adjustment Project of 4th Water Supply System in Han River Down Stream. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
58
Korea Development Institute (2017e). Project of Preliminary Feasibility Study Standard Guideline Revise & Complement Research in Water Resources Sector. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
59
Korea Development Institute (2018a). Improvement Project of Water Damaged Region in Gyeyang River. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
60
Korea Development Institute (2018b). Water Supply System Adjustment Project of South Area in Geum River. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
61
Korea Development Institute (2018c). Industrial Waterworks(operates seawater ) project of Daesan Maritime Industrial Region. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
62
Korea Development Institute (2018d). Preliminary Feasibility Study of Research to Reflect Social Values. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
63
Korea Development Institute (2019). Disaster Prevention Project of Wonju River. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
64
Korea Development Institute (2021). Preliminary Feasibility Study Detailed Guidelines for Implementation General Sector Research. Sejong: Korea Development Institute.
65
Ministry of Economy and Finance (2020). Preliminary Feasibility Study Application Guidelines. Sejong: Ministry of Economy and Finance.
66
You, J. Y., Kim, G. H., Yeo K. D., and Shim, M. P. (2008). Improvement Direction for Feasibility Analysis of Water Resources Projects by Analyzing Preliminary Feasibility Analysis Projects. Journal of Korea Water Resources Association. 1545-1549.

Korean References Translated from the English

1
기획재정부 (2020). 예비타당성조사 운용지침. 세종: 기획재정부.
2
유재영, 김길호, 여규동, 심명필 (2008). 예비타당성조사 사례분석을 통한 수자원사업 타당성분석의 개선방향 설정. 한국수자원학회 학술발표회 논문집. 1545-1549.
3
한국개발연구원 (2000). 수도공급시설 연계운영사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
4
한국개발연구원 (2002a). 괴산댐 재개발사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
5
한국개발연구원 (2002b). 매화댐 재개발사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
6
한국개발연구원 (2002c). 신풍․성덕댐 재개발사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
7
한국개발연구원 (2002d). 오봉댐 재개발사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
8
한국개발연구원 (2002e). 임진강 군남 홍수조절지 축조사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
9
한국개발연구원 (2003a). 속사댐 건설사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
10
한국개발연구원 (2003b). 안의댐 건설사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
11
한국개발연구원 (2003c). 이안천댐 건설사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
12
한국개발연구원 (2003d). 한강하류권 급수체계구축 1차사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
13
한국개발연구원 (2004a). 아산만 방조제 배수갑문 확장사업 예비타당성조사. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
14
한국개발연구원 (2004b). 임진강 초평도 유황(물흐름) 개선사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
15
한국개발연구원 (2004c). 충남 남부권 광역상수도 사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
16
한국개발연구원 (2005a). 경북 중부권 광역 상수도 건설사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
17
한국개발연구원 (2005b). 목감천 방수로·도림천 지하방수로 건설사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
18
한국개발연구원 (2006a). 중규모 용수개발(안동 북부지구)사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
19
한국개발연구원 (2006b). 철동지구 농수이용체계 재편사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
20
한국개발연구원 (2007). 백신지구 중규모 농촌용수개발사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
21
한국개발연구원 (2008a). 구미III단계 광역상수도사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
22
한국개발연구원 (2008b). 보현댐 건설사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
23
한국개발연구원 (2008c). 송리원 다목적댐 건설사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
24
한국개발연구원 (2008d). 주암댐 치수능력 증대사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
25
한국개발연구원 (2009a). 금강살리기 군수지구 생태하천조성사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
26
한국개발연구원 (2009b). 금강살리기 세도지구 생태하천조성사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
27
한국개발연구원 (2009c). 낙동강살리기 금호지구 생태하천조성사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
28
한국개발연구원 (2009d). 낙동강살리기 동촌지구 생태하천조성사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
29
한국개발연구원 (2009e). 남강댐 재개발사업 및 부산․경남권 광역상수도사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
30
한국개발연구원 (2009f). 대암댐 대체저류지 및 도수관로 건설. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
31
한국개발연구원 (2009g). 영산강살리기 동림지구 생태하천조성사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
32
한국개발연구원 (2009h). 영산강살리기 함평3지구 생태하천조성사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
33
한국개발연구원 (2009i). 임진강수계 농촌용수공급대책사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
34
한국개발연구원 (2009j). 충주호내 단양수중보 건설사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
35
한국개발연구원 (2009k). 한강하류권 2차 급수체계 조정사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
36
한국개발연구원 (2010a). 낙동강살리기 양산1지구 생태하천조성사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
37
한국개발연구원 (2010b). 낙동강살리기 양산2지구 생태하천조성사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
38
한국개발연구원 (2010c). 농업용저수지(백곡) 둑높임사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
39
한국개발연구원 (2010d). 대청댐계통(III) 광역상수도 건설사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
40
한국개발연구원 (2010e). 영산강 유역 농업용저수지 둑높임사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
41
한국개발연구원 (2011a). 달산댐 건설사업 및 포항(II)단계 공업용수도 건설사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
42
한국개발연구원 (2011b). 영양댐 건설사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
43
한국개발연구원 (2011c). 충주댐계통 공업용수도 사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
44
한국개발연구원 (2012a). 고덕산업단지 용수공급시설 설치사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
45
한국개발연구원 (2012b). 낙동강 강변여과수 사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
46
한국개발연구원 (2012c). 삽교방조제 배수갑문 확장사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
47
한국개발연구원 (2012d). 안동댐 토사류 유입방지시설 건설사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
48
한국개발연구원 (2012e). 한강하류 3차 급수체계 조정사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
49
한국개발연구원 (2013a). 공기업·준정부기관 사업 예비타당성조사 수행을 위한 일반지침 연구. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
50
한국개발연구원 (2013b). 수도권(Ⅱ) 광역상수도 용수공급 신뢰성 제고사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
51
한국개발연구원 (2014). 광양(Ⅰ) 공업용수도 용수공급 신뢰성 제고사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
52
한국개발연구원 (2016a). 광주천 도심하천 생태복원(지방하천정비) 사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
53
한국개발연구원 (2016b). 용봉천 생태하천 복원사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
54
한국개발연구원 (2016c). 점동지구 다목적 농촌용수 개발사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
55
한국개발연구원 (2016d). 예비타당성조사 제도의 이해. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
56
한국개발연구원 (2017a). 목감천(지방하천) 치수대책사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
57
한국개발연구원 (2017b). 서낙동강수계 국가하천환경정비사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
58
한국개발연구원 (2017c). 충남서부권 광역상수도 사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
59
한국개발연구원 (2017d). 한강하류 4차 급수체계 조정사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
60
한국개발연구원 (2017e). 수자원부문 사업의 예비타당성조사 표준지침 수정·보완 연구(제5판). 세종: 한국개발연구원.
61
한국개발연구원 (2018a). 계양천 수해상습지 개선사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
62
한국개발연구원 (2018b). 금강남부[2차] 급수체계 조정사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
63
한국개발연구원 (2018c). 대산임해산업지역 공업용수도(해수담수화) 사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
64
한국개발연구원 (2018d). 예비타당성조사의 사회적 가치 반영을 위한 연구. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
65
한국개발연구원 (2019). 원주천 하천재해 예방사업. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
66
한국개발연구원 (2021). 예비타당성조사 수행을 위한 세부지침 일반부문 연구. 세종: 한국개발연구원.
Information
  • Publisher :Korean Society of Disaster and Security
  • Publisher(Ko) :한국방재안전학회
  • Journal Title :Journal of Korean Society of Disaster and Security
  • Journal Title(Ko) :한국방재안전학회 논문집
  • Volume : 14
  • No :3
  • Pages :1-16
  • Received Date : 2021-08-15
  • Revised Date : 2021-09-05
  • Accepted Date : 2021-09-14
  • DOI :https://doi.org/10.21729/ksds.2021.14.3.1
Journal Informaiton Journal of Korean Society of Disaster and Security Journal of Korean Society of Disaster and Security
Online submission
  • KISTI Current Status
  • KISTI Cited-by
  • KCI 문헌 유사도 검사
  • orcid
  • open access
  • ccl
Journal Informaiton Journal Informaiton - close